Showing posts with label McDonalds. Show all posts
Showing posts with label McDonalds. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 28, 2015

One of the worse quarters in McDonald's recent history

A couple of days ago the fastfood giant released its report for the fourth quarter and also the full year. In this post I will present some key data from the report and my own reflections. 

Results For The Fourth Quarter Compared With The Same Quarter In 2013.

- Sales decreased by 7% to 6,6 billion dollars (7).

- Net profit was 1,06 billion for the period, an decrease of 21% (1,4).

- Earnings per share (EPS) decreased by 19% to 1,13 dollars (1.4).

Results For The Financial Year 2014.

- Sales decrease by 2% to 27,4 billion dollars (28).


- Net income was 4,7 billion for the period, an decrease of 15% (5,6).


- Earnings per share (EPS) decreased by 8% to 4,82 (5.55).


Factors That Influenced The Results Negatively.
  • Tough competition primarily in the US continues to weigh heavy on McDonald's profitability. Sales decreased 1.7% and operating earnings with 15% in the final quarter due to lower guest influx and sales in existing restaurants.
  • McDonald's is also losing market share in its largest established market, Europe, where sales fell by 1% and operating profit by 14%. Russia and Ukraine has had weak development in the European segment, were the company's restaurants closed down due to the conflict in Ukraine.
  • McDonald was also sentenced to pay the equivalent of 0.31 dollars per share in additional taxes, which is a one time cost.
  • The supplier scandal in China had a negative impact on profits equivalent to about 0.23 dollars per share.
What Was Positive Then?
  • On 18 September McDonald rose its dividend by 5% for the 39th year in a row.
  • The fast food giant also bought back the equivalent to 2% of its total share count during 2014.
  • McDonald's continues to open and renovate restaurants around the world. The company will also focus on increasing the number of franchise restaurants primarily outside the United States.
My View Of The Report
This report is one of the worse from McDonalds in recent years. If we disregard non-recurring items the result does not look as bad, but regardless of one-off items, earnings growth is negative. Here is how sales and EPS has developed during the past five years:


Development of Revenues And EPS During The Last Five Years - McDonalds
The picture above is pretty clear since EPS and Revenues are at their lowest levels since in 2010. McDonald's CEO Don Thompson admits that the company continues to face headwinds and that market environment is challenging. He stressed that the company is going to continue to focus on improving the customer experience, and he remains convinced that McDonald's can boost growth and create value for shareholders over the long term.

In order to boost growth McDonalds must increase the comparable sales and guest influx in existing restaurants within the established markets of Europe and the US. The company has for this reason developed three strategies to increase their relevance with their customers:
  • Modernization and improvement of McDonald experience (trademark, restaurants, menus and customer service).
  • Shorteing and simplifying the ordering and payment process with new technology such as mobile, web, and payment solutions. McDonalds has for this reason joined Apple Pay.
  • Use existing resources more effectively to realize the points above.
To date, the implemented measures have apparently not had the desired effect since McDonalds is losing customers to competitors in their two main markets. I think that the fast food chain needs to reinvent its self somehow, to be able to reach mine and later generations (1980 to 2000) to really get the growth ontrack.

McDonald's is, despite the recent growth problems, a stable and shareholder-friendly company, that has raised dividends for 39 years in a row. I believe that the fast food giant is worth buying up to a price of about 87 dollars. You can, as usual, find my Watch List in main menu.

What is your view on McDonalds latest report?

Friday, November 28, 2014

Is This Quintessential Fast-Food Giants Days Numbered?

This is my first of many stock analysis and what better candidate to start with than the shareholder friendly fast-food giant - McDonalds. In the following post I will examine the company against my investment criteria. 

Distinct Competitive Advantage (Moat)?
Bigger is better (economies of scale). McDonald's is the world's largest fast-food chain with 35,000 restaurangs that are located in 118 countries, with an extensive distribution network to serve them all. Just like Walmart, McDonalds has a great bargaining power over it's suppliers, since many of them are dependent on McDonalds which in turn means that the company can buy in large quantities at reasonable prices. McDonalds is also one of the market leaders in most of its markets, even though the competitors have been catching up lately. China is the a market where McDonalds has struggled the most to make a significant footprint.

Location, location, location! Since McDonalds was first to market in many countries, the company has been able to secure great locations for it's restaurants. Management puts a great deal of effort into finding the very best locations. McDonalds often times own both the land and property, and if that's not the case they secure long-term leases.

McDonalds is still a strong brand in most countries and has a huge advertising budget that few companies can match.

McDonalds also has a proven franchise model (about 80% of restaurants are franchised restaurants), where the franchisee is responsible for the mayor part of the risk. Franchise restaurants account for big part of McDonalds revenue, which comes from rental fees, franchise fees and percentage of all restaurant sales. 

All these reasons above makes McDonalds stand out from it's competitors with strong cash flow and high margins. Morningstar believes that McDonalds has a wide moat and I can only agree with them. McDonalds gets a pass on this criterion.

A Truly Global business?
The US accounts for 32%, Europe 39% and APMEA (Asia / Pacific, Middle East, Africa) for 23% of the revenues.

Global Revenues McDonalds
Of revenue from Europe the UK, Germany and France account for about 51%. Of the proceeds from APMEA China, Australia and Japan stands out with 56% of the revenues. McDonalds is multinational company in the true sense of the word. McDonalds passes this criterion. 

Strong Owners?
I'd like to se a business that I own to have strong owner behind it with financial muscle. I usually prefer a company that is family owned, since you tend to take better care of things close to home.
The bigest shareholders are: Vanguard Group, State Street Corporation and BlackRock Institutional Trust Company. McDonalds passes this criterion. 

A Business That is Easy to Understand?
McDonalds business is easy to understand and get a grip on. The company aquires restaurants at strategic locations and sells a tested and established concept with a strong brand to franchisees. The concept is further developed (menus, décor, etc.) and franchisees are trained. The McDonalds brand is managed by means of a huge advertising budget and the company receives most of it's revenue from the franchisees.
McDonalds passes this criterion. 

Rising Earnings Per Share (EPS), That Have Grown on Average at Least in Line with the Dividend for 10 Years?
McDonalds passes this criterion since the average increase per year was about 15% over the period. 

Development of EPS and Revenue During The Period: 2004-2013
Sales growth has also contributed to the growth of VPA and averaging approximately 6% per year over the same period.

McDonalds also has an extensive repurchase program of shares where they spend an average of 3-4 billion dollars each year. The number of shares has fallen by more than 20% during the period 2004-2013 as a result of share repurchases.

The chart below shows how the company's earnings per share (EPS) and profit margins have developed during the period 2004-2013.
Development of EPS and Profit Margin During The Period: 2004-2013
The profit margin has grown from about 9.1% in 2003 to almost 20% in 2013! 
McDonalds does get a pass on this criterion. 

A Dividend that has on Average Risen over the Period of 10 Years?
McDonalds has increased its dividend every year since 1976. This is how the dividend has developed over the past 10 years.
Development of Dividend Per Share and Dividend Payout Ratio During The Period: 2004-2013
The average dividend growth per year has been about 22%. I can't see McDonalds dividend streak coming to an end anytime soon, although the dividend growth has slowed down considerably in recent years. The payout ratio has risen during the period and in 2013 the payout ratio stod at 56,2% and is about 66% right now. McDonalds passes this criterion.
 
A Company with Financial Strength?
McDonald's balance sheet is strong compared to it's peers, although there is some leverage there. The equity ratio (shareholders' equity) is about 43%. The interest coverage ratio is about 15 which means that they can cover their interest costs nearly 15 times. Free cash flow has been stable during the period and has covered the dividend by a margin.

The big real estate portfolio of restaurants also add strenght to the balance sheet in my opinion. 
McDonalds passes this criterion. 

Risks and Uncertainties That May Affect Future Earnings?
I want to assure myself that political, regulatory, business and other specific risks that may affect a company's future earnings are as few as possible and preferably manageable.

Health trends have and will continue to put pressure on the fast food industry, McDonalds has however adapted by renewing their menus and offered healthier options in the past.

Tough competition primarily in the US, but also abroad, continues to put a damper on McDonald's profitability. Sales have dropt since last year due to lower guest traffic and comperable sales in existing restaurants in the U.S.

The political risk will always be there since brand is tightly asssociated with the U.S. and the american way. Recent shut downs of restaurants in because of alleged sanitary violations Russia attests to this fact.

Regulatory risk is another threat that McDonalds faces. There is a widespread dissatisfaction among restaurant employees in the United States over the low minimum wages, which is ceating bad press for the chain.
The supplier scandal involving expired meat in China has also had an substantial negative impact on profits this year thus far.


Even though McDonalds has hit a rough patch right now I think the company's strong position in the market place, strong cash flow and the it's abilty to over time adapt give it the tools to cope in this enviroment in times ahead. McDonalds passes this criterion. 

Summary and Valuation
McDonalds meets all of my investment criteria. In my eyes, McDonalds is a solid company with competitive advantages as evidenced by the margins. Steadily increasing EPS and dividends have made McDonald's into an attractive stock to own historically. The big question is what the future looks like.

EPS and dividend growth have slowed down considerably lately. EPS for the last four quarters is down 9% compared to last years full year results. A big part of the recent decline in profitability has do to with the stiff competition and bad press that McDonalds has experienced in the U.S as well as a slow down in Europe. Other factors affecting earnings are the recent meat scandal in China and to a lesser extent the closing down of restaurants in Russia.

McDonalds hopes to increase sales in the U.S. segment by creating a more focused menu, since analysts have pointed out the chain's extensive menu as one of the reasons that sales have dropped lately.
To strengthen the results in APMEA (mainly China) McDonalds will focus on rebuilding confidence in the brand and updating the menu options so that it's more adapted to local preferences. The company will also open more restaurants in the region.

McDonalds will have spent a total of 5 billion on dividends and share repurchases at the end of the year. The share repurchases will contribute to VPA growth by between 2.5 - 3%.


The bigest key to speeding up the VPA-growth is to increase the comparable sales and guest the count in existing restaurants within the established markets. The company has conceded that it hasn't done enough in this area and has for this reason developed three specific strategies to increase their relevance for the customer:
  • Modernization and improvement of McDonald experience (trademark, restaurants, menus and customer service).
  • Shorteing and simplifying the ordering and payment process with new technology such as mobile, web, and payment solutions. McDonalds has for this reason joined Apple Pay.
  • Use existing resources more effectively to realize the points above.
McDonalds is, despite the recent problems, one of the most stable and share friendly company you can own in my opinion. What Am I then willing to pay for such a high quality company that I believe Mcdonalds to be?

Valuation
My Price Cap is equivalent to 83,5 dollars. The Price Cap constitutes the price I'm willing to pay at the most for a given stock. The Price Cap is the average value obtained when Fair Price 1 (based on dividend growth and dividend yield) and Fair Price 2 (based on sustainable EPS and Sustainable P/E ratio) are compared. My Price Cap for McDonalds is based on the following assumptions:
  • I estimate that McDonalds will have an average dividend growth rate going equivalent to about 8% going forward.
  • I estimate sustainable EPS to be roughly 5,5 dollars and sustainable P/E-Ratio, based on the company's qualities to be 18.
This concludes my stock analysis on McDonald's. My plan is to publish several equity research in the coming weeks.

Have a nice day!